Just like every other fan of New Orleans and its music, I was looking forward to HBO's "Treme," a dramatic series that takes place just a few months after Hurricane Katrina. It's been sobering to re-visit the trauma inflicted upon that great city. But it's certainly been a pleasure to see familiar locales and hear all that great music.
But after the first two episodes, there are a few things that are keeping this from being the experience I was hoping for. For starters, some of the characters in the show are over-the-top caricatures. Luckily, for a change from TV norm, that doesn't apply to the black characters. Actors Wendell Pierce (pictured at right) as a hard-luck musician, Clarke Peters as a Mardi Gras Indian chief trying to restore his tribe and his soul, and Khandi Alexander as a bar owner and Pierce's ex-wife, are all turning in riveting performances. But Steve Zahn (left) as a DJ and cultural know-it-all and John Goodman as a self-righteous, liberal college professor are almost too much to watch. Zahn's character, in particular, is so annoying that he makes me want to leave the room whenever he's onscreen. Those stereotypes surely exist in New Orleans, but I'm wondering if the primarily white creative team has gone out of its way to make the black characters more deeply dimensional.
And in their zeal to express their understandable love for New Orleans music, and to introduce a larger audience to some of the city's lesser-known treasures, the filmmakers occasionally present some clumsy exposition. Case in point: in episode two, Pierce's character is headed for a gig when he bumps into the great local musician Trombone Shorty. Pierce greets him thus: "Hey, Trombone Shorty!" That is Troy Andrews' stage name, but the effect is like greeting a friend by his first and last names. I can't imagine any of Andrews' real-life friends addressing him as anything but "Shorty." But the filmmakers are determined to educate the heathens that
this is someone you must know! You got that? That's T-R-O-M-B-O-N-E S-H-O-R-T-Y!
Speaking of New Orleans musicians, they're as much a part of the cast as the actors. And that's a problem. God bless Allen Touissant and Kermit Ruffins (middle), but they're so self-conscious that it makes their scenes painful to watch. (The same goes for marquee slummer Elvis Costello.)
Finally, there was a scene in episode two in which a pair of white street musicians belittle a trio of visiting college students who request some "real New Orleans music"--"When the Saints Go Marching In." Treme executive producer and creator David Simon was deservedly praised for his handling of race in the fantastic series "The Wire." But again, in this scene he seems to be exhibiting a bit too much deference. How much more interesting, and tense, would that scene have been had the street musicians been black?
All that said, I'll be watching the rest of the series. The good outweighs the bad--if only by a crawfish or two. And, of course, there's great music like this from the mighty Mr. Ruffins:
Download 1-02 Drop Me Off In New Orleans